Context
Eight-person team, $1.2M ARR, founder running outbound between customer calls. Two attempted SDR hires hadn't worked out. Apollo + Salesloft were in place; nothing was producing reliable pipeline.
The problem
The team was trying to sell to a too-broad ICP — anyone running cloud infrastructure at 50+ employees. Sequences were product-led, lists were stale, replies were going untriaged. Founder was spending 11 hours a week prospecting and resented every minute of it.
What we changed
- Cut the ICP from 'cloud-using SaaS 50–500' down to two segments: post-Series-A platform teams hiring infra roles, and mid-market data orgs running specific stack signals.
- Rebuilt the list with Clay enrichment around tech stack + hiring triggers. Verified contacts; killed about 40% of the original list as wrong-persona or stale.
- Wrote three messaging angles per segment — problem-led, trigger-led, and contrast — and ran them as an A/B/C across the eight weeks.
- Added a clean weekly readout: positive reply by segment, meeting bookings, meeting outcomes, and what got cut.
Execution
Three reps on the engagement (one strategist, two operators). Two-week experiment cycles. Daily reply tagging. Mid-pilot we cut the mid-market segment based on poor conversion and doubled down on platform teams.
What the team learned
The mid-market segment we'd planned to lead with wasn't responsive — at all. The trigger-led angle outperformed the problem-led angle by 2x in the platform segment. The team hired their first SDR after the pilot with a working playbook in hand.